Every year, when complaint figures for health insurance companies are reported, the total number of complaints against each company tends to draw the most attention.
On its own, that figure says very little about the quality of service a policyholder actually receives.
The more useful question is how a company’s complaints compare with the size of its business.
A recent report by Grant Thornton Bharat, titled Retail Health Grievance Analysis of Standalone Health Insurers (SAHI), examines this issue using publicly available data for FY26.
The report studies the top five standalone health insurance companies: Star Health and Allied Insurance, Care Health Insurance, Niva Bupa Health Insurance, Aditya Birla Health Insurance and Manipal Cigna Health Insurance. Star Health is the largest of the five, holding 52.8 per cent of the retail health policies in the group.
Why the total number of grievances can be misleading
Insurance companies disclose grievance figures that may include several types of policies, such as individual health insurance, group health insurance, personal accident insurance and travel insurance.
This makes it difficult to understand the actual experience of individual health insurance customers.
To make a fair comparison, the Grant Thornton Bharat report separates grievances related to individual retail health insurance from those relating to other types of insurance.
The five companies together received 51,967 grievances during FY26. Of these, 44,097 were related to individual retail health insurance.
The report uses these 44,097 grievances to compare the companies on a more equal basis.
How do the five insurers compare?
One of the most useful ways to compare insurance companies is to calculate the number of grievances received for every 10,000 policies.
According to the report, the five insurers recorded between 23.09 and 56.23 grievances per 10,000 policies. The average for the group was 27.52.
Three companies performed better than this average, while two recorded significantly higher grievance rates. One company’s rate was approximately twice the average.
Notably, the three largest insurers in the group, led by Star Health, recorded grievance rates below the group average even though they serve the most customers.
This shows why simply looking at the total number of grievances can give a misleading picture of an insurer’s performance.
Another way to judge insurers fairly
The report also uses a measure called the Grievance Contribution Index. In simple terms, it compares a company’s share of total grievances with its share of total insurance policies.
For example, if a company has 10 per cent of all policies and receives 10 per cent of all grievances, its performance is broadly in line with its size. Its index would be 1.0.
If it receives a larger share of grievances than its share of policies, its score will be above 1.0. This indicates that it is receiving more grievances than might be expected from the size of its business.
A score below 1.0 means the company is receiving a smaller share of grievances than its share of policies.
The report found that the scores of the five insurers ranged from 0.84 to 2.04.
The company with the highest score, 2.04, had the smallest policy base. It accounted for just 2.8 per cent of the policies but received 5.7 per cent of the grievances.
Another relatively small insurer held 7.8 per cent of the policies but accounted for 11.4 per cent of grievances, giving it an index of 1.46.
In contrast, all three of the largest insurers had scores below 1.0. This means their share of grievances was lower than their share of policies.
These figures suggest that the size of an insurance company alone does not determine how well it serves its customers.
Why individual insurance plans also matter
The report goes a step further by examining the performance of individual insurance products.
This is important because not all insurance companies sell the same mix of policies. Some depend heavily on a few major products, while others have a more diverse range.
At one insurer, its leading products accounted for 83.6 per cent of its policies and 93.9 per cent of its grievances. At another, the leading products accounted for only 48 per cent of its policies.
Such differences show why an insurer’s overall grievance rate may not tell the complete story. The performance of individual plans also needs to be examined.
Scale and good service can go together
The report provides an interesting example.
Among the leading insurance products examined, Star Health Assure covered 30.64 lakh policies, the largest policy base in the comparison.
Despite its size, it recorded the lowest grievance rate among the products studied, at 19.47 grievances per 10,000 policies.
In comparison, other major insurance products recorded higher grievance rates, ranging from 25.64 to 34.96 grievances per 10,000 policies.
Another interesting finding was that the flagship product of the insurer with the highest overall grievance rate had a relatively low rate of 23.81 grievances per 10,000 policies. However, this plan covered only 1.16 lakh policies.
These examples make one point clear. Grievance performance is best judged by the grievance rate, not by the total count alone.
What should customers look at before buying health insurance?
For people buying health insurance, the lesson is straightforward. Do not choose or reject a company simply because it has a high total number of grievances.
Instead, look at the number of grievances per 10,000 policies. Where information is available, also examine the grievance record of the specific insurance plan you are considering.
A lower grievance rate can be a useful indication of better product design and customer service. However, customers should also consider other factors, such as the policy’s coverage, exclusions, claim settlement conditions, hospital network and premium.
The Grant Thornton Bharat report highlights an important point: a fair assessment of an insurance company requires more than counting grievances. It requires comparing those grievances with the number of policies and examining how individual products perform.
The bottom line
Every complaint represents a policyholder who may have faced a problem, often at a difficult time when medical care is urgently needed.
Complaints should therefore be taken seriously. But judging insurance companies fairly is equally important. The real measure of an insurer’s performance is how many grievances it receives relative to the number of policies it has issued.
Looking at the grievance rate, rather than the headline figure, can help customers make better informed decisions when choosing health insurance.